idea ·Mean Streets (1973)

Too much red

In 1975 Michael Powell wrote to Scorsese to say Mean Streets used too much red. Scorsese had got the red from Michael Powell.

  • colour
  • lighting
  • atomic
  • influence
  • scorsese
  • powell

Back in 1975, he'd written to me after first seeing Mean Streets to say that he liked it, but I used too much red - this from the man who had red all over his own films, which was where I'd got it from in the first place!

— Scorsese on Scorsese, sos 80

The "he" is Michael Powell, director of The Red Shoes and Black Narcissus, whom Scorsese would help rescue from obscurity and whose editor, Thelma Schoonmaker, later married. So the most famous colour decision in the film, the red of Mean Streets — Tony's bar, is a quotation, and its source thought it was overdone.

Ebert reads the red as "the color of sex, blood, and guilt" ([[Roger Ebert — Scorsese by Ebert|Scorsese by Ebert]], unpaged). Both things are true: a colour can carry a meaning in the film and a debt outside it. A student who knows only the first is reading the image; one who knows the second is reading the filmmaker.

There is also a Powell nod at the start of the film: the projector in the title sequence recalls Peeping Tom (smc 46). See Mean Streets — the opening.

Powell kept giving notes. Ten years later he fixed the ending of After Hours (Michael Powell wrote the ending). See Michael Powell.

A case for Colour. Compare The red tint over the bloodbath, where Scorsese's red three years later was a price paid to a ratings board, not a debt to a master.