SoHo before the money, 1984
After Hours was shot at night in a neighbourhood of artists' lofts that money was about to discover. The film catches the moment, and treats the uptown visitor as the intruder.
- setting
- lighting
- context
- setting
- new-york
- gentrification
The datum
The film was shot at night in SoHo and TriBeCa, where Scorsese was then living: "I was living in TriBeCa at the time" (Kelly, unpaged). Kelly describes the attraction:
Scorsese liked the nighttime quiet and emptiness of pre-gentrified SoHo and TriBeCa. Like the Russian cemetery in Mean Streets, the taxicab sanctuary of Travis Bickle, and the boxing ring roped off from the howling crowd in Raging Bull, SoHo is a place apart, especially "after hours."
— Kelly, unpaged
Griffin Dunne remembers it as a secret: "Soho then was uncharted territory for people who lived above 14th Street. We knew it, but no one else did" (Dunne on After Hours (2024)).
The change under way
The urban-space chapter of the Companion puts a date on it:
SoHo was, by 1985, the epicenter of a new wave of culture-led redevelopment in America's cities. Yet the SoHo of After Hours is still very much a neighborhood "in transition," as the developers would say, and Hackett is marked as decidedly "other" from the moment he steps out of his taxi.
— smc 354
Its reading of the film turns on who belongs.
In Mean Streets the streets belong to the men who grew up in them. "Here, Scorsese reverses that
polarity; the space of SoHo 'belongs' to characters like Kiki and Gail, and Paul is distinctly
marked as an interloper" (smc 355). By the end of the night there are wanted posters with his face on them.
The chapter's conclusion: "In his farcical treatment of one uptown man's misbegotten attempts to
find downtown love, Scorsese offers us a poignant study of the social consequences of rapid
gentrification" (smc 356).
What it does to the images
The streets look empty because they were. The Companion: "The streets of SoHo are eerily quiet
and dark, with a scarcity of streetlights and seemingly no automobile traffic or ambient light"
(smc 355). Scorsese adds that the new fast film stock could see more than the eye: "for some
scenes we had to take the street lights down because it was so bright" (sos 99). So the
darkness is partly real and partly made.
Ebert, in 1985, thought New Yorkers would recognise it: "For New Yorkers, parts of the film will no doubt play as a documentary" (Scorsese by Ebert, unpaged, where the scan reads "New Torkers").
Why it matters
A Setting case with a date stamp. The same few blocks are "just a few blocks west of the
Little Italy of Mean Streets, and yet there is no hint of the shared geography that the two films
inhabit" (smc 355). Twelve years apart, one neighbourhood is home and the next is a foreign
country. Compare New York was Los Angeles, where Scorsese had to fake the city, and
Church and street in Little Italy.